Monday, July 28, 2014

Update: Mid-2014 Soybeans Cycle and PTV Analysis

 In our last update we talked about the possibility that soybeans could rally for the rest of the year going close to or above 1650¢ per bushel in November 2014 aligning with Gann's 45 years cycle harmonic.

 We also mentioned that even though we were expecting a top in May 2014 we underestimated it, thinking that the market would rally shortly after and continue with its uptrend. Instead the market had a great decline.

 The present post addresses the possibility that a rally could be under way based on cycle and PTV[1] analysis. An important harmonic of Gann's 14 years cycle was due to turn between July 22nd-26th. It coincided with the completion of PTVs related to the Square Of Twelve in both the cash and futures markets.

 Cash soybeans cycle and PTV analysis

 Figure 1 is a daily price-time chart for cash soybeans at Decatur, Illinois from 2008 to the present time. It contains the harmonic of Gann's 45 years cycle due to turn in November 2014. It also shows two important harmonics of Gann's 14 years cycle turning in late July 2014.

 
Cash soybeans. Gann's 45yrs and 14yrs cycle harmonics. PTVs related to the Square Of Twelve. GrainMarketAnalysis
Figure 1
Daily cash prices for soybeans at central Illinois from 2008 to 2014. Harmonics of Gann's 45yrs and 14yrs cycles. A PTV projection from 2008 to 2014 and PTVs related to the Square of Twelve completing in July 2014.

 Figure 1 shows that these harmonics of Gann's 14 years cycle aligned with the spike top of March 2008, the secondary top of early July 2009 and the final bottom of December 14th, 2011. As mentioned, they are again due to turn in late July 2014.

 At the time that this cycle turns in July 2014, a couple of PTVs are completing. The PTV defining the decline from the last top of May 2014 measures 290, which is equal the second Square of Twelve. Also, the PTV defining the market action from the secondary top of late July 2013 equals 431.47, or exactly the third Square of Twelve.

 Note that this last PTV has the same length as the one defining the decline from late Aug-early Sep 2012 to Apr 2013. Additionally, late July 2014 is an anniversary from Jul 2013 top and the all time high cash top of July 2012.

 The 2008-2014 PTV projection from our last update is included here as well, as a possible price-time target if cash beans rallies.

 November soybeans cycle and PTV analysis

 Figure 2 is a daily price-time chart for November soybean futures from 2013 to 2014. As in the previous figure, it contains both the harmonics of Gann's 45 years and 14 years cycles.

 
Figure 2
Daily November soybean futures from 2013 to 2014. Harmonics of Gann's 45yrs and 14yrs cycles. PTVs related to the Square of Twelve completing in July 2014.
 Figure 2 shows that since late August 2013 there are several PTV with lengths related to the Square of Twelve in November beans. PTV AB, defining the initial decline from August to October 2013 measured 147.96, or the first Square of Twelve.

 Between late August and mid-September 2013 there was a multiple top formation. PTV A'C which defined the decline from mid-September top to the late January 2014 bottom measured 325.90, or the first Square of Twelve times the square root of five, √5 x 144 = 321.99.

 PTV CD, which defined the uptrending market from January to the top of May 2014 measured 206.08, which equals the first Square of Twelve times the square root of two, √2 x 144 = 203.65.

 The last PTV, DE, defining the decline from May to July 2014 measures 227.90. The sum of PTVs CD + DE = 433.98, which is the third Square of Twelve, or 3 x 144 = 432. Additionally, PTV A'E which would define the complete market action from mid-September 2013 to late July 2014 equals 406.51, or 2√2 x 144 = 407.29.

 Summary

 There is a projection indicating that cash soybeans could go near or above 1650¢ per bushel if it aligns with a top in Nov-2014 and Gann's 45 years cycle.

 If this is true, prices should rally in the near future. With this in mind, there are a couple of harmonics of Gann's 14 years cycle turning in late July 2014. At the same time there are several PTV completing in the cash and futures markets. These could indicate that a rally is due thus taking prices higher.

 However we think it is important to keep in mind that the typical soybean behavior after a May top is to decline all the way into seasonal lows in October, or into an August-September bottom.

 [1] PTV stands for Price-Time Vector. This concept was introduced by Bradley Cowan in his writings. Both PTV and Price-Time Vector are trademarks of Bradley Cowan.

 Soybeans 2014 Fall Seasonal Low

 Ricardo Da Costa
 Grain Market Analysis

7 comments:

  1. Are you saying that the soybean market could make a bottom into August-September(because of the May top) and still rally into 11/11/14 making a high around the 1650 level? Or were you saying that if it didn't bottom in late July it would not be able to rally into Nov. and not reach the 1650? Thanks for your clarification.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tim,

      This projection comes as result of continuing Cowan's work from MSI. But right now, I am not very confident that soybeans will rally and complete this PTV reaching 1650¢ by November 2014. The fact that the market broke the Jan-2014 Nov-2013 bottoms makes me doubtful. I am waiting and seeing.

      Delete
    2. Having said that, together the lengths of the PTVs connecting the Jul-2013 top, Nov-2013 bottom, May-2014 top and Aug-2014 bottom (?) add up to 7x144 = 1008.

      Also, if the PTVs connecting the Jul-2012 top, Nov-2012 bottom and Jul-2013 top are included the sum adds up to 1720.99 or 12x144 = 1728.

      It would be nice to see soybeans rally and reach that target. But as I said above, right now I am not confident at all of this PTV projection.

      Delete
  2. Since it seems that our initial projection will not be met, we sat down to review our work:

    It is possible that our PTV projection coming from Dec-2008 is not correct. Perhaps what we were waiting for in terms of PTVs (from our study of MSII) completed in Sep-2012 at the historical high of 1790¢. Our problem is that it doesn't strictly follow the rules laid out by B.Cowan in MSII. Time will prove our mistake or confirm our initial projection.

    Also, we concluded that an underlying cubic structure completed on Nov-2013 indicating much higher prices. Nevertheless both the Nov-2013 and Jan-2014 bottoms were broken. Then it is most likely that it was just the completion of a face of the structure.

    Thank you all for your interest in our writings.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Cash Soybeans:
    from the 2008 high, the following PTV's are calculated:

    1. Sep 2011 bottom= 1012 (7x144= 1008)
    2. Aug 2013 bottom= 1318 (9x144= 1296)
    3. Aug 2014 bottom= 1605 (11x144= 1584)

    Next number in this series in 13x144= 1872

    The rules set out in MSII (and all of his work) leave alot to the imagination :)
    Time will tell


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Interesting analysis Steve. I think you meant Dec 2011 bottom in your first PTV, right?
      If I may add, from Jul 2008 top to the Jun 2009 top you get 3x144.
      Thanks for sharing this with us.

      Delete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete